UPDATE: **SOLD** Was $2500.
This looks like a fair price.
“1969 Jeep CJ 5. 3 speed manual. Original Buick V6 engine. 31×10.50×15 tires. Bikini top. Front tow bar. Runs and drives. Very little surface rust. Has large crack in windshield. $2500 or best offer. No Trades please.”